What I am Learning from You
A reflection on what you have told me this week – about a sense of exasperation with politics, the search for ways out of this mess, and the longing for optimism amidst all the dark chaos
This essay is cross-posted from Steady, where Democracy Americana is now mainly hosted.
I am also making it available here for those who prefer to read (and perhaps share!) the piece in the Substack app. If you want to support my work, you can head over to Steady and become a paid subscriber.
The intro to this piece is free for everyone. If you want to read more than the preview or gain access to the audio version of the newsletter, please consider becoming a paid member of Democracy Americana, which is solely funded by readers and constitutes my main source of income as an independent writer.
Without your support, I will not be able to continue this work. Please know that I am immensely grateful for your generosity!
If a paid membership is currently not an option, the best way to support Democracy Americana is to share this piece here on Substack as well as on social media - and recommend my work to people you think might be interested.
You can also subscribe to the free version of the newsletter here on Substack: I will transfer all new subscribers coming in here over to Democracy Americana’s new home to make sure you are not missing anything.
Dear all,
This is not a regular post, but a quick follow-up to the piece I wrote earlier this week – and an attempt to respond to the many messages I have received from you. I promise I’ll try to keep it somewhat brief.
As you’ll recall, after six months of writing Democracy Americana full time, I was giving you an update on how it’s been going, on the state of the newsletter, and on the challenges of making it work as an independent writer. I have received a ton of messages in response. Between all the comments under the piece, direct messages across all the social media sites, and emails, I believe I have heard directly from over ten percent of my paying subscribers / members. That may not constitute a representative sample in a strict statistical sense, but it certainly is a significant response. And there are certain recurring themes in what you have told me that I find extremely important. I wasn’t planning on writing a follow-up, but as I have been making may way through all the messages (and if you haven’t heard back from me, I promise: you will!), I am feeling the urge to reflect a little bit on what you are telling me.
Let me start here: Almost all the messages I have received have been extremely kind and supportive. Some of the feedback was critical – but in a thoughtful, considerate, productive way. And so many of you have really put in significant time and effort to engage with me. I could not possibly ask for more. I am humbled and grateful. A little overwhelmed, honestly – mostly in a good way, because I am frankly not used to this kind of outpouring of support. And I just want to say: Thank you. I hope that you all know that your support means a lot to me. I feel honored to write for you, and I take that responsibility very seriously.
I am also a little bit overwhelmed because there is so much to grapple with, so much to ponder in your replies and comments. I am very much still in the middle of reflecting on everything you have told me. Here are some recurring themes in your messages: A general news fatigue and a sense of being exasperated with politics (and the political media landscape), a frustration with “How we got here” pieces that don’t address the question of how we get out, and a longing for hope and optimism amidst all the dark chaos. If you’ll indulge me, I’d like to share some thoughts on what I am learning from you - and what I am taking away from your feedback.
The rest of this piece is reserved for paid members of Democracy Americana.
If you are not a member, but still want to read Democracy Americana, fear not: I will keep publishing free long-form essays regularly.
But if you can, please consider becoming a paid member over on Steady: You’ll gain access to additional member-exclusive essays every week - and members also have access to the audio versions of all my writing in podcast form wherever you get your podcasts.
Most importantly, if you value this independent work, please know that it is your support and your generosity that is making it possible. Democracy Americana is entirely reader-supported and my main source of income as an independent writer.